5 Carat Natural Mined Diamond Price

A 5 carat diamond is the ultimate expression of luxury, prestige, and refined beauty. Such a substantial diamond offers extraordinary brilliance and a remarkable presence, making it the perfect centerpiece for exceptional engagement rings or heirloom jewelry. At 1-800 Loose Diamonds, we specialize in helping you confidently select the perfect 5 carat diamond by clearly explaining the factors influencing its price, quality, and value. Here’s your comprehensive guide to purchasing a stunning 5 carat diamond.

5 Carat Diamond Price List

Below is a general pricing overview to help you understand typical price ranges for 5 carat diamonds. Prices can vary significantly based on specific diamond characteristics, certifications, brand markups, and market availability.

Clarity / Color D–F (Colorless) G–H (Near Colorless) I–J (Near Colorless)
FL-VVS $150,000–$500,000+ $120,000–$350,000 $90,000–$250,000
VS $100,000–$300,000 $85,000–$250,000 $65,000–$180,000
SI $70,000–$200,000 $60,000–$160,000 $45,000–$120,000

These prices represent general guidelines. Actual diamond prices depend heavily on precise characteristics such as cut, certification, fluorescence, and retailer pricing strategy.

How Much Does a 5 Carat Diamond Cost?

A 5 carat diamond can range significantly in price—from about $45,000 for diamonds with more noticeable inclusions and warmer hues, up to over $500,000+ for exceptional diamonds graded colorless (D–F), flawless (FL–VVS clarity), and featuring superior cuts. Most buyers seeking exceptional beauty with strong value choose diamonds in the near-colorless range (G–H) with VS clarity, typically priced between $85,000 and $250,000.

diamond img
Cushion, 5.00 Carat

CARAT

5.00 Carat

COLOR

D

CLARITY

VS1

$1,538.00

see details
diamond img
Cushion, 5.00 Carat

CARAT

5.00 Carat

COLOR

D

CLARITY

VVS2

$1,253.00

see details
diamond img
Cushion, 5.00 Carat

CARAT

5.00 Carat

COLOR

D

CLARITY

VS1

$1,275.00

see details
diamond img
Cushion, 5.00 Carat

CARAT

5.00 Carat

COLOR

D

CLARITY

VVS1

$1,196.00

see details
diamond img
Cushion, 5.00 Carat

CARAT

5.00 Carat

COLOR

E

CLARITY

VS1

$6,135.00

see details
diamond img
Cushion, 5.00 Carat

CARAT

5.00 Carat

COLOR

E

CLARITY

VVS1

$1,224.00

see details

Why Is a 5 Carat Diamond Engagement Ring So Extraordinary?

A 5 carat diamond is truly spectacular. Its generous size highlights stunning brilliance, sparkle, and intricate facet detail. Such a diamond symbolizes lasting commitment, exceptional taste, and undeniable luxury—perfectly suited for engagement rings, milestone anniversaries, and generational heirlooms.

Factors Affecting 5 Carat Diamond Pricing

Several essential factors influence diamond pricing:

  • Cut: Precision cutting greatly impacts sparkle, brilliance, and overall appearance.
  • Color: Diamonds graded D–F (colorless) command premium prices for rarity; near-colorless diamonds (G–H) offer excellent beauty and value.
  • Clarity: Diamonds with fewer inclusions (FL–VVS clarity) command higher prices, while VS–SI clarity grades provide great value with minimal visible imperfections.
  • Shape: Round brilliant diamonds typically carry higher prices due to demand and complexity of cut; fancy shapes like oval, cushion, or emerald often offer better value.
  • Certification: Diamonds certified by trusted labs, especially GIA, ensure quality and generally have higher resale value.
  • Brand Markup: Luxury brands often add significant markups; diamonds from reputable independent jewelers like 1-800 Loose Diamonds typically offer better value.
  • Fluorescence: Diamonds with strong fluorescence may appear hazy, reducing their price slightly, whereas faint fluorescence usually doesn’t affect appearance significantly.

How Color Affects the Cost of a 5 Carat Diamond

Diamond colors range from D (colorless) to Z (noticeably tinted). Diamonds in the D–F range are highly sought after for their pure white color and fetch the highest prices. Near-colorless (G–H) diamonds appear virtually white and offer excellent value. Diamonds graded I–J carry slight warmth but can appear beautifully balanced in complementary settings.

How Clarity Influences the Cost of a 5 Carat Diamond

Diamond clarity indicates the presence and visibility of inclusions:

  • FL–VVS: Extremely rare and valuable, nearly flawless under magnification.
  • VS–SI: Minor imperfections usually invisible to the naked eye; excellent combination of visual quality and value.
  • I1–I3: Inclusions easily visible without magnification, generally less desirable in larger stones.

How Cut Impacts the Cost of a 5 Carat Diamond

Cut quality significantly affects a diamond’s brilliance, fire, and visual impact. An Excellent or Ideal cut diamond maximizes beauty, commanding higher prices. Even diamonds with exceptional color and clarity will look unimpressive if poorly cut. Investing in the highest cut quality ensures your 5 carat diamond sparkles brilliantly.

How Shape Affects the Cost of a 5 Carat Diamond

Round brilliant diamonds typically cost the most due to their popularity and challenging cutting process. Fancy shapes—like oval, emerald, cushion, and princess—generally offer excellent value and distinctive styling. Choosing a fancy shape often provides the opportunity to acquire greater carat weight or improved quality at lower prices per carat.

How GIA Certification Influences 5 Carat Diamond Pricing

GIA (Gemological Institute of America) certification is the industry gold standard. Diamonds certified by GIA are often priced higher due to verified accuracy and trustworthiness, significantly increasing buyer confidence and long-term investment value.

How Brand Markup Affects the Cost of a 5 Carat Diamond

Luxury jewelry brands typically increase diamond prices significantly due to marketing costs and brand reputation. At 1-800 Loose Diamonds, we eliminate unnecessary markups by offering high-quality diamonds and exceptional service at transparent, fair prices.

Fluorescence: Its Impact on Diamond Pricing

Fluorescence is the subtle glow some diamonds emit under ultraviolet (UV) light. While faint fluorescence generally doesn’t impact visual appeal significantly, stronger fluorescence can cause larger diamonds (like 5 carats) to appear slightly cloudy, reducing their market value. Be sure to examine fluorescence levels when selecting your diamond.

Determining the Exact Price of Your 5 Carat Diamond

Follow these steps to determine the precise value of your specific diamond:

  • Evaluate the 4Cs: Review cut, color, clarity, and carat weight thoroughly.
  • Check Certification: Always confirm your diamond is graded by reputable labs like GIA.
  • Consider Shape & Fluorescence: Recognize how these subtle factors affect pricing.
  • Compare Prices: Look at similar stones from reputable sellers.
  • Request Detailed Quotes: Ask for clearly itemized price breakdowns to ensure confidence in your purchase.

Common Mistakes When Buying a 5 Carat Diamond Engagement Ring

  • Ignoring Cut Quality: Even high-carat diamonds need superior cut for maximum brilliance.
  • Skipping Certification: You risk paying premium prices for lower-quality stones.
  • Paying Excessively for Brand: Premium brands don’t necessarily offer better diamond quality.
  • Overlooking Fluorescence: Strong fluorescence can negatively impact the visual appeal.
  • Choosing Shape Based Solely on Trends: Prioritize how the shape complements your personal style and appearance

Additional Considerations for Your 5 Carat Diamond Purchase

  • Setting Style: Solitaire or halo settings highlight the exceptional size and sparkle of a 5 carat diamond.
  • Metal Choices: Platinum or white gold beautifully accentuates higher color grades, while yellow or rose gold can complement warmer tones.
  • Insurance & Appraisals: Protect your substantial investment through appropriate insurance coverage and accurate appraisals.
  • Jeweler Reputation: Partner with jewelers who prioritize transparency, ethical sourcing, and personalized service—like 1-800 Loose Diamonds.

Final Notes from 1-800 Loose Diamonds

A 5 carat diamond represents unmatched luxury, lasting beauty, and exceptional taste. Understanding the factors influencing its price and quality ensures you’ll confidently select the perfect stone to symbolize your personal story.

At 1-800 Loose Diamonds, we’re committed to providing expert guidance, transparent pricing, and outstanding customer service, helping you find the ideal 5 carat diamond to treasure forever.

Ready to begin your journey? Contact us or visit our website at 1-800 Loose Diamonds today. Our diamond specialists are here to assist you every step of the way.



Expert Advice from 1800 Loose Diamonds

FREE Diamond Consultation

Schedule a complimentary consultation to get personalized adviceon diamond quality, pricing, and custom design options — from trusted professionals with decades of experience.