Diamonds are prized for their brilliance and rarity, but not every sparkling stone is the real deal. The market is full of fake diamonds and convincing imitators, so knowing how to spot an authentic diamond is essential. Whether you own diamond jewelry pieces or are in the middle of the diamond buying process, you want to be confident you’re getting an authentic natural-born diamond rather than a fake stone. Fortunately, there are several simple Diamond At-Home tests and expert tips that can help you distinguish a real diamond from imitations.
Before diving into testing methods, it’s important to understand what “real” means. Natural diamonds are mined from the earth, while lab-grown diamonds (also called lab-created diamonds or synthetic diamonds) are made in a lab. Both natural and lab diamonds are genuine diamonds – they share the same chemical structure of carbon atoms. (In fact, contrary to popular belief, lab-grown diamonds are true diamonds; their only difference from mined diamonds is their origin.) By contrast, common diamond substitutes are made from other materials and have different properties.
Common Diamond Simulants:
-
Cubic Zirconia (CZ) – A synthesized colorless zirconia crystal. Flawless with high dispersion (lots of rainbow sparkle); denser (heavier) than an equivalent diamond. A cheap diamond alternative often used in costume jewelry.
-
Moissanite – A lab-made gem of silicon carbide. Nearly as hard as diamond and very brilliant, but shows excessive rainbow-like reflections and may exhibit a faint gray or yellow tint.
-
White Sapphire – A natural durable gemstone (colorless sapphire). Very hard (Mohs 9) but lower in refractive index, so it often appears slightly dull or “glassy” under white light compared to a diamond.
-
Glass/Crystal – A common fake material. Much softer and less dense than diamond (often contains tiny bubbles). Glass imitation stones scratch easily and lack a diamond’s sharp sparkle.
Simple At-Home Tests for Diamond Authenticity
You can perform several tests at home to identify a diamond. Use a combination of these diamond tests for more reliable results – a combination of factors is more telling than any single test alone.
1. The Water Test
Fill a glass with water and gently drop the loose stone in. A genuine diamond, being very dense, will sink straight to the bottom. Many fake diamonds will float at the surface or hover in the middle. (If it floats, you clearly have a fake stone on your hands.)
2. The Fog Test (Breath Test)
Breathe on the stone to cover it with a thin layer of fog (moisture). If the fog dissipates almost instantly, the stone is likely real. If it stays foggy for a couple of seconds (clearing at a much slower rate), it’s probably fake – real diamonds are excellent heat conductors, so they disperse heat (and thus clear the fog) quickly.
3. Check the Setting & Engraving
If the diamond is mounted, examine the ring’s setting and metal. Real diamonds – especially larger stones – are usually set in high-quality metals like white gold, yellow gold, or platinum, not in a cheap setting. Look for stamps inside the band indicating the type of gold (10K, 14K, 18K, etc.) or other hallmarks. A large center diamond in a flimsy mount, or a “C.Z.” engraving on the setting, are clear red flags that you might have a fake.
4. Light Refraction & Sparkle Tests
A real diamond’s facets intensely bend and refract light. One quick check is to place the stone flat side down over printed text (or a dot drawn on a white piece of paper). Try to look through the pointed end of the stone. If you can read the letters or see a circular reflection of the dot, the stone is likely not a diamond. An authentic diamond will distort and scatter the light so much that you can’t clearly see the text or dot through it.
Next, observe how the stone sparkles. Authentic diamonds (regardless of diamond shape) shine with a brilliant mix of white light and colored “fire”. In contrast, many simulants produce excessive rainbow-like reflections or else have a much duller overall sparkle. For example, a diamond’s flashes of white light are strong and accompanied by subtler colored flashes, whereas a cubic zirconia or moissanite might throw overly vivid rainbow colors (a disco-ball effect) or not sparkle as sharply.
5. The Heat Test (Diamond Lighter Test)
For this test, use caution. (Ensure you have heat-proof tweezers or fireproof gloves.) Heat the stone with a lighter flame for about 30 seconds, then immediately drop it into a glass of cool water. A fake stone like glass or quartz will crack or even shatter due to the rapid temperature change (thermal shock and contraction of heat). A true diamond will be unharmed. Diamonds can withstand extreme heat and disperse heat so rapidly that this quick temperature change doesn’t affect them.
Expert Verification and Professional Testing
If you’re still unsure or dealing with an expensive piece, consider professional help. Jewelers or professional gemologists often use an electronic diamond tester tool – a handheld electronic device that measures heat conductivity – for a quick check of a stone’s authenticity. Keep in mind that some imitators like moissanite can fool basic testers, so experts may employ specialized equipment (for example, devices that also test electrical conductivity or other diamond test methods). For ultimate certainty, you can send the stone to a gemological lab for a diamond certificate. Certified diamonds come with an official grading report that verifies the diamond’s authenticity and quality (e.g. its 4 Cs). A reputable diamond jewelry store (such as 1-800 Loose Diamonds) or a trusted gemologist in town can give you authoritative confirmation that your stone is the real deal.
Conclusion
Distinguishing a real diamond from a fake is achievable with the right knowledge and a few simple tests you can perform at home. These straightforward methods are an excellent first step to filter out clear diamond substitutes, helping you protect your investment and enjoy peace of mind. However, remember that no single test provides 100% certainty. It's the combination of factors and tests that reliably identifies genuine diamonds.
When you're looking for absolute assurance, consulting professional gemologists or reputable diamond jewelry stores is always the safest route. Experts, such as those at 1800 Loose Diamonds, can utilize specialized equipment and perform comprehensive diamond tests under laboratory conditions to definitively confirm the authenticity and quality of your gemstones.
Whether you're examining a cherished family heirloom, purchasing an engagement ring, or expanding your gemstone collection, knowing how to identify high-quality, authentic diamonds empowers you in your diamond buying process. While synthetic materials and copycat gemstones may look convincing, nothing truly compares to the unique sparkle, brilliance, and beauty of an authentic diamond, be it a natural diamond or a lab-grown diamond.
With these expert tips and simple at-home tests, you're well equipped to confidently discern genuine diamonds from their imitations, ensuring every piece of jewelry you own is the real deal.